Building a brand takes years of effort, trust, and investment. But one duping competitor can threaten it all. When another business sells deceptively similar products, it puts your reputation and revenue at risk. This is exactly what a passing off trademark protects against.
In India, courts actively safeguard brand goodwill. For example, the Calcutta High Court recently invalidated the “Protifix” trademark. The court ruled it deceptively similar to “Protinex” because it could mislead ordinary consumers. This is part of the passing off trademark’s features.
Passing off does not require a registered trademark. It defends the reputation, trust, and hard-earned goodwill of a business.
This guide covers passing off trademarks and how trademark registration protects your brand.
What is Passing Off in Trademarks in India?
Passing off is a serious trademark violation in India that can harm a business’s goodwill and reputation. It is a legal action that protects businesses from unfair competition by stopping others from misrepresenting their goods or services as yours. The law safeguards your brand identity, reputation, and the trust you’ve built with your customers.
What’s amazing is that this law works even for unregistered trademarks. Misrepresentation can be intentional or accidental. Courts intervene when customers are likely to be confused. It also protects logos, packaging, trade dress, and marketing materials.
Legal Basis for Passing Off Trademark in India
In India, passing off under Section 27 of the Trademark Act, 1999, allows businesses to take legal action even without a registered trademark. The relevant section lays down that the claimant must prove:
- Goodwill or reputation in the market.
- Misrepresentation by another business.
- Damage or likely damage caused to the claimant.
Indian courts, such as in the Amritdhara Pharmacy vs Satyadeo Gupta (1963) case, have upheld that copying branding or packaging can mislead customers. Passing off ensures fair competition and protects both businesses and consumers.
Key Elements of Passing Off Under Trademark
To succeed in a passing off unregistered trademark claim, a plaintiff must prove:
1. Goodwill or Reputation: The claimant must show that their brand has goodwill or reputation in the market. Claimants can prove goodwill through the use of distinctive names, logos, packaging, or other marks.
The public should be able to associate these marks with the claimant’s goods or services.
2. Misrepresentation: The defendant must have made a misrepresentation. This can be using a similar mark or copying aspects of the plaintiff’s trade dress, product design, or packaging.
Misrepresentation can be intentional or accidental. The key is that it confuses the public about the origin of goods or services.
3. Damage to Reputation or Goodwill: The defendant’s action must have caused or is likely to cause damage to the claimant’s brand. This can appear as consumer confusion, loss of sales, dilution of brand value, or harm to the reputation built over time.
Protecting a brand goes beyond a name or logo; it means safeguarding customer trust and protecting your business name.
Types of Passing Off Trademark in India
Passing off can appear in different forms. Each type involves misrepresentation that confuses customers.
Below, we explain the main types with real case examples:
1. Classic Passing Off
Classic passing off happens when a competitor copies a product’s branding or packaging to mislead customers into believing it belongs to another brand. In Cadbury Gems vs James Bond, the Delhi High Court found that the defendant’s “James Bond” chocolates used packaging and visual elements deceptively similar to Cadbury Gems. The similarity was likely to confuse ordinary buyers, particularly children, and the court held that such imitation amounted to passing off.
2. Reverse Passing Off
Reverse passing off occurs when someone takes your actual product and sells it under their own name. This harms your brand’s recognition and goodwill. A classic international example is the Reckitt & Colman “Jif Lemon” case. A competitor used packaging that mimicked the iconic lemon-shaped bottle of Jif juice. The court ruled that this misled consumers.
3. Extended or Indirect Passing Off
Extended passing off involves subtle forms of confusion. Exact copying is not required. The overall impression of the trade dress or design misleads customers. For instance, in Lush Ltd. vs Amazon.co.uk (UK), using Lush’s branding styles in sponsored ads could injure the brand’s reputation. The court ruled this could mislead consumers.
These examples show that passing off is not just about copying a name. It includes packaging, branding style, trade dress, and even store identity. In short, any element that creates customer confusion and harms your brand qualifies.
Registering a trademark is essential to protect your business name from imitation and misuse.
How to Protect Your Brand from Passing Off?
Protecting your brand goes beyond registration. Even unregistered marks are safeguarded, as courts prevent others from misrepresenting their goods or services as yours.
Here are clear steps to shield your brand effectively and reduce the risk of passing off:
1. Register Your Trademark
Start with formal registration on the IP India Trademark Portal.
Early registration reduces the risk of others using confusingly similar marks and gives you statutory remedies under Section 29 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999.
Registering early reduces the chance of others using confusingly similar marks.
2. Create a Distinct Brand Identity
- Use a unique name, logo, packaging, and trade dress.
- Ensure your branding stands out visually and conceptually.
- Courts find it easier to judge misrepresentation when the brand is distinct.
Distinct branding makes it harder for competitors to imitate your products.
3. Monitor the Market Regularly
- Keep track of competitors and new products in your industry.
- Use trademark watch services and RegisterKaro’s free trademark class search tool to spot conflicts early.
- Early detection allows you to act before damage occurs.
Prompt action makes your brand protection proactive.
4. Educate Your Customers
- Inform your audience about authentic products.
- Use your website, social media, and marketing campaigns.
- Educated customers are less likely to be confused by imitations.
This strengthens the connection between your brand and its customers.
5. Take Quick Legal Action
- Act immediately when you spot passing off.
- Send a cease-and-desist notice to the infringer.
- If necessary, file a court case to seek injunctions, damages, or an account of profits.
- Under Section 135 of the Trademark Act, courts can order the destruction of infringing goods.
Protecting your brand from passing off requires action, vigilance, and preparation. Don’t wait for confusion to harm your reputation. Be proactive.
Get expert help with trademarks and brand protection. RegisterKaro offers professional services to safeguard your business.
Difference Between Passing Off and Infringement of Trademark
People often confuse passing off trademarks with trademark infringement. Both protect brands, but they are different. Understanding the difference is crucial for safeguarding your business.
1. Passing Off: This type of passing off happens when a competitor misleads customers by copying your brand.
- Protects unregistered trademarks.
- Focuses on goodwill and reputation built over time.
- Courts look at misrepresentation and customer confusion.
Example: Tiffany & Co. v. Rajesh Jewellery House (Delhi High Court, 2013)
The defendant sold jewelry using packaging and branding resembling Tiffany & Co.’s iconic style. The court held this to be passing off, protecting Tiffany’s established goodwill and ensuring customers were not misled by the imitation products.
2. Trademark Infringement: It occurs when someone uses a registered trademark without permission. It violates the legal rights of the brand owner.
- Protects registered trademarks only.
- Focuses on the exclusive legal rights granted by registration.
- Courts examine whether the defendant used the registered mark without permission.
Example: Louis Vuitton Malletier v. Manoj Khurana (2012) – The defendant used bags and products imitating Louis Vuitton’s signature design and logo. The Delhi High Court ruled it as passing off and trademark infringement, restraining the defendant from selling imitation products.
The court emphasized protecting the established goodwill and reputation of Louis Vuitton in India against misleading consumers.
Legal Remedies for Passing Off Trademarks
If a party proves a passing off claim, they can seek several legal remedies. The following remedies protect the brand and prevent further harm:
1. Injunction: An injunction is a court order that stops the defendant from continuing the passing off. Courts can issue preliminary injunctions to prevent immediate harm or permanent injunctions for long-term protection. This is usually the first remedy a business seeks to protect its reputation and goodwill.
2. Damages: A business can claim damages to recover losses caused by passing off. This may include lost sales, harm to brand reputation, and legal fees. Damages ensure that the affected company is compensated for the financial and reputational harm suffered.
3. Account of Profits: The court can order the defendant to surrender any profits earned through passing off. This ensures that the wrongdoer does not benefit from deceiving customers. The claimant is entitled to receive the profits that the defendant gained by using the misleading mark, reinforcing fair competition and protecting the brand’s rightful market position.
4. Destruction of Infringing Goods: Courts can order the destruction or delivery of products that mislead consumers. This stops further misuse of the plaintiff’s brand. It also ensures that infringing goods do not remain in the market to confuse customers.
These remedies not only safeguard your brand but also send a clear message: copying your hard-earned reputation comes at a price.
RegisterKaro simplifies passing off trademark matters in India. We guide you through filing, evidence collection, and legal formalities, ensuring your brand gets protection against unfair competition.
Focus on building your business while we handle the legal process and documentation efficiently. Contact RegisterKaro today!
Frequently Asked Questions
To prove a passing off trademark claim, a brand owner must show three things: established goodwill, misrepresentation by a competitor, and likely damage to reputation or sales. The court examines whether customers would confuse the defendant’s mark or product with the claimant’s. The claimant must present evidence of market recognition, branding history, and concrete examples of competitor conduct that misled ordinary consumers.
Related Posts
Get your business a separate legal identity, limited liability protection, and easier access to funding.
Register a Limited Liability Partnership with flexible structure and lower compliance requirements.
Start your business journey as a single founder with limited liability protection.
Empowers entrepreneurs with government recognition, tax benefits, funding support, and simplified compliance.
Give your business a premium address and professional presence without the cost of a physical space.
Ensure legal, financial, and regulatory obligations and maintain the company’s good standing legally.
Register for Goods and Services Tax to legally collect tax from your customers.
Register as a Micro, Small, or Medium Enterprise to avail government benefits.
Obtain your FSSAI license to legally sell and serve safe food in India.
